|
Skep's Pick: A CMDB is like a Swiss bank account This link is here because...(hover) The Skeptical Informer, August 2007, Volume 1, No. 7
![]() The newsletter of the IT Skeptic. All the IT skeptical news that is fit to print... and then some! Much comment activity on the blog has been around certification, and in particular dissatisfaction with the Version 3 Fundamentals course.
I think this dissent stems from a more fundamental problem. As a result of integrating all the "Lost Books" of Version 2, ITIL Version 3 is an order-of-magnitude broader and more complex than the red-and-blue-books-version2 that most people work with. This is an advance for the industry, a step up in competency. Unfortuantely it is only a step up if you are already standing on the Version 2 step. If you have not embarked on the service management journey yet, then Version 3 represents a high wall. Chuck the Five Books at a beginner and they'd run screaming. This is what is happening with the Fundamentals course: jam the five books into three days and the result is deep shock. Version 3 provides no intermediate steps up the wall. Version 2 is the only "beginner's ITIL" available. OGC and TSO are hell-bent on killing off Version 2 as fast as possible. But Version 2 will not go anywhere until an "ITIL for Dummies" comes out as part of V3 complementary guidance. Or people will start turning to alternatives such as FITS. The other book we desperately need is "How to Implement ITIL" including a progressive series of steps up that wall. The Five Books say where to get to but they still say little about how to get there. I've criticised the development of version 3 in the past for not being open and inclusive enough and I think this is a consequence. If ITIL Version 3 had been tested with a wider audience along the way which included organisations with no knowldghe of ITIL then this would have emerged as a problem sooner. But it wasn't. It was developed from and tested on the existing ITIL community, and mostly the private little club of the ITIL aristocracy. So if any reader wants to gain fame and save the world, write a decent book on How to Do ITIL. These remarks are probably not the best way to introduce the next bit of news: Sharon Taylor has agreed to be an occasional guest blogger on the IT Skeptic (see below). I'm hoping this move will take the quality of debate on the blog to the next level. On another note, let me share a comment from me from the blog re itSMF:
This month I'm determined to limit myself to a few interesting comments. Let's see how successful I can be: Another vision | Visitor (not verified) itSMF | jvbon Members and mission | Visitor (not verified) Well said... | Visitor (not verified) [More itSMF (and IoSM) comments here] Over the ATOs' dead bodies! | skeptic V3 Foundations Syllabus - Yikes! | Liz (not verified) [And many more comments on that thread.] Yanks are engaged | Visitor (not verified) LOL | brian_dayton public domain | jvbon judge not by the cover but the content | ITMaturity Lean and ITIL | Visitor (not verified) Virtualization and CMDB federation | Marv Waschke (not verified) [And lots more meaty CMDB content on that thread.] Coming of the Messiah | Visitor (not verified)
|
|
|
Please forward this newsletter to someone who would enjoy it
Subscribe | Blog |
Blog RSS |
Podcast RSS | Feedback
© Copyright 2006-2009 Two Hills Ltd www.twohills.co.nz. All rights reserved
Permission is required to reproduce this content in any form. Brief extracts may be used without permission if attributed with a link to the site.
"The IT Skeptic™", "The Skeptical Informer™", "The IT Swami™", "Chokey the Chimp™" and "BOKKED™" are trademarks of Two Hills Ltd.
ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark and a Registered Community Trade Mark of the UK Office of Government Commerce ("OGC"). ITIL® is registered in the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.
COBIT® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Information Systems Audit and Control Association and the IT Governance Institute.
Microsoft® is a Registered Trade Mark of Microsoft Corp. in the United States and/or other countries.
CMM® is a Registered Trade Mark of Carnegie Mellon University.
ISO® is a Registered Trade Mark of the International Organisation for Standardisation.
This newsletter and its contents are neither associated with nor endorsed by the OGC or any other organisation.
The contents of this newsletter are unmoderated submissions from authenticated and unauthenticated users. As such they cannot and do not represent the views of Two Hills Ltd.
Buy your books here to support this blog:


























Made in New Zealand 
Recent comments